The present Two Head Studies of a Man is a significant addition to the relatively small confirmed oeuvre of the outstanding but enigmatic Antwerp Baroque master Pieter van Mol. Van...
The present Two Head Studies of a Man is a significant addition to the relatively small confirmed oeuvre of the outstanding but enigmatic Antwerp Baroque master Pieter van Mol. Van Mol, had he stayed in Flanders, rather than accompanying Rubens to Paris in 1625 to assist his fellow Fleming in executing the Marie de Medici cycle (as suggested by David Jaffe), arguably might rank as the fourth member of the great Antwerp triumvirate of Rubens, van Dyck, and Jordaens. Indeed this work was formerly attributed to Jacob Jordaens.
Pieter van Mol’s formative years were spent in the Antwerp workshop of Artus Wolffort, who like van Mol’s other great influence, Peter Paul Rubens, was trained in the studio of Otto van Veen. By 1623/4 van Mol was a master of the Antwerp Guild of Saint Luke; by 1631 he is recorded in Paris, where he set up a studio. He was appointed court painter to the French King Louis XIII in 1637, and he received the title of 'peintre ordinaire du roi’. On 19 February 1640 Pieter van Mol married Anne van der Burght (or Anna van der Burch) in the Church of Saint-Sulpice in Paris. The couple had eight children, of whom Robert van Mol became a painter and engraver. Around that time he had also been appointed court painter to the French Queen, Anne of Austria. Commissioned also to paint such major works as The Adoration of The Shepherdsfor the Abbey of Saint-Germain-des-Près (now in the Musée des Beaux- Arts Marseille), he was a founding member of theAcadémie Royale de Peinture et de Sculpture, which was established nearby in 1648 by Cardinal Mazarin.
Recorded in the collection of the Marquesses of Lothian since at least the early 18th century, the present picture has a distinguished provenance, which likely extends to the Marquesses’ predecessor, Robert Kerr, 1st Earl of Ancram (1578 -1674). Ancram, was famously portrayed by Jan Lievens. The Earl was an avid collector who lived between Britain and the Low Countries – first exiled from Whitehall for a duel in which he killed a companion of the George Villiers, Duke of Buckingham, and then during the English Civil War. A staunch Royalist, Ancram served as Gentleman of the Bedchamber to King Charles I.
The present work sits within the Antwerp artistic practice of workshop tronies, first popularized by mannerist masters of an earlier generation such as Frans Floris. Theses heads could be reused multiple times for different figures in larger compositions. The present work - with its strong nose, prominent cheek bones and ruddy complexion - bears many similarities to van Mol’s Jesus(location unknown).
Van Mol’s adept style ranged from almost deliberately retrograde works with extremely fine facture, apparently in homage to the Flemish primitives, such as his Lamentation of Christconserved in the Musée des beaux-arts de Valenciennes, to the present free execution of Two Head Studies of a Man, and the aforementioned, Jeune Homme à la Mitre. Both the present work and the Louvre painting exude van Mol’s painterly brio and flair, which rivals that of van Dyck or Jordaens, in whose orbit this study was first placed. Scholars have however since recognised the present study as a masterful and characteristic work from the hand of van Mol.
(possibly) William Kerr, 3rd Earl of Lothian (1605-75); (possibly) Robert Kerr, 1st Marquess of Lothian (1636-1703); William Kerr, 3rd Marquess of Lothian (1690-1767), by 1726, when recorded in the inventory, and by descent in the family at Newbattle Abbey and Monteviot House to; Michael Kerr, 13th Marquess of Lothian (b.1945), by whom sold in the following; Two Great Scottish Collections: Property from the Forbes of Pitsligo and the Marquesses of Lothian; sale, Sotheby's, London, 28 March 2017, lot 445, as 'Circle of Sir Peter Paul Rubens'; sale, Christies, London 25 November 2022, lot 131, as ‘attr. to Jacob Jordaens’.
Literature
Newbattle Abbey inventory, c. 1726/27; Newbattle Abbey inventory, 1752, as 'two heads ... Lucca Jordano';
Newbattle Abbey inventory, c. 1788; Newbattle Abbey inventory, March 1833, no. 261; Newbattle Abbey inventory, May 1878, no. 261 (Front Stairs); J.M. Gray, Notes on the Art Treasures at Newbattle Abbey, Mid-Lothian, Edinburgh, 1887, p. 43, as by Jacob Jordaens;
Newbattle Abbey inventory, 21 May 1900, no. 261 (Front Stairs);
Newbattle Abbey inventory, December 1901, p. 43, as by Jacob Jordaens (Staircase);
Monteviot House inventory, 14 July 1989, no. 261, as by Jacob Jordaens (Library).